Case Review: Dismissal under Dignity at Work Policy Upheld by the WRC

Summary of the Respondent’s Case

A complaint was raised to the respondent regarding a breach of the company’s Dignity & Respect at Work policy. Training had been provided to all employees on the policy. Following an investigation and formal disciplinary, the complainant was dismissed by way of a letter for gross misconduct. The respondent stated the dismissal was reasonable and fair.

Summary of the Complainant’s Case

The incident occurred on a work night out when the complainant attended his colleague’s leaving party. The leaving party was an out of hours event organised by employees.

Following the night out, a work colleague made a complaint regarding the complainants’ behaviour. It was said he made a derogatory remark about a work colleague.

There was an ongoing slagging culture among the employees. The culture of slagging occurred during working hours as well as out of hours work-related events. Disrespectful, insulting and inappropriate words relating to some equality grounds specifically, sexual orientation, ethnic origin and mental qualities were used by all employees without any complaints being raised or staff feeling insulted.

The complainant stated the outing was not “an associated event in the course of employment”. It wasn’t organised by the respondent. The incident was a one-off isolated incident, as it was not repeated could not be considered bullying and may only be an affront to dignity at work.

The dismissal letter the complainant was issued did not detail why summary dismissal was the most appropriate sanction.

The Adjudicators Outcome

The WRC Adjudicator found that dismissal was fair, in an unusually short decision, concluding:

In considering [the claimant’s] arguments, the whole purpose of a Dignity at Work Policy is to curtail such a culture and to ensure it does not get out of hand. The Claimant’s colleague took exception to his remarks and made a complaint which was investigated and founded to be true. Furthermore the Claimant held a senior position, a manager and should have known better. I accept that the Respondent had no choice but institute a dismissal if the Dignity at Work policy was to mean anything.”

Learning Points

This case highlights the importance of;

  1. Having clear policies and procedures in place in relation to Dignity & Respect at Work;
  2. Providing training to all staff around the area of dignity & respect at work;
  3. Taking complaints regarding breaches of the policy seriously;
  4. Ensuring previous culture of ‘slagging’ does not mean inappropriate behaviour is acceptable;
  5. Treating all work related nights out regardless whether arranged by management as work events.

It’s important to note that this outcome is a surprising one. Not only was the outcome unusually short, the fact the Adjudication officer said dismissal was a proportionate sanction was also surprising.  Generally a once of incident would be considered an affront to a dignity at work and handled in line with a company grievance procedure and only repeated inappropriate behaviour would be considered a breach of the dignity and respect at work policy.

Where a complaint is raised regarding a breach of the dignity & respect at work policy, it’s important to seek advice regarding the appropriate steps to take.

If you have any queries regarding this case please do not hesitate to contact the advice line on 01 886 0350

Book a call with a consultant

Complete the form below and a consultant will call you as soon as possible.

Book a call with a consultant

Complete the form below and a consultant will call you as soon as possible.

Latest Resources

New whistleblowing rules in force from January 2023

The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Michael McGrath, recently confirmed that the Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Act 2022 will come into force on 1 January […]

Fair distribution of tips to be mandatory from December 1st

The Government passed the Payment of Wages (Amendment) (Tips and Gratuities) Act 2022 earlier this year in July. This week, the Tánaiste confirmed that this new law […]

The new broom sweeps clean: Musk’s redundancies will need to comply with Irish employment law

Elon Musk hasn’t wasted making changes at Twitter, with him making approximately half of the company’s global workforce redundant. While labour laws in the US […]